(Enlarged picture of left)

Left Back: Bathsheba "Bethie Hutton" (Arthur Edward Hutton & Oscar Israel Hutton -twins), Anna Liza Hutton.  1910-1914
in Cherry Valley near Butlerville, Jennings Co. Indiana.
[I'm dating this picture according to wedding ring Anna Liza has on (her marriage 1910 & the fact that they (JJ) built new home in Butlerville 1918.

 Edward Hutton & Mary Ann Baumgardner Hutton
He died in 1890.  Their 50th wedding anniversary would
have been 1883.  Est. picture date between 1883-1890.